Let’s start with some things written in the blurb and reviews. According to the blurb, “The story of [where’s the ‘the’?] clandestine love of Julien’s mother breaks through Violette’s carefully constructed defences to reveal the tragic loss of her daughter, and her steely determination to find out the truth.” No. Julien’s arrival quickens the pace of the revelations but Violette didn’t quite live behind “carefully constructed defences” nor shy away from the truth. Through these revelations, we know that she conducted her own investigations before she even meets Julien. One reviewer says, “An intriguing mystery about a long-disappeared husband and a lost child…” No, too. Intriguing yes, but the story is not largely about Philippe’s disappearance. It is about Violette and the main mystery is about how/why Leonine and her friends died in the fire. Also, do you call a dead girl a “lost child”...